5 Critical Questions to Ask When Hiring a VP of Sales for Your B2B SaaS Startup

5 Critical Questions to Ask When Hiring a VP of Sales for Your B2B SaaS Startup

‍

Hiring the right VP of Sales can make or break your company's growth, especially for early-stage startups. This role is at the center of scaling revenue, building out a team, and setting the tone for your sales culture. But how do you know you’re bringing on someone who can handle the unique challenges and growth of your business? Here are five key questions to help you uncover the right fit.

‍

1. At a high level, what did the first 3, 6, 9+ months look like in your last role when scaling from Series X to Series X? (The stages may differ)

‍

Startups move fast, and a VP of Sales who thrives in this environment needs to have experience building teams from the ground up. Ask them to walk you through their process—at an earlier stage company – did they roll up their sleeves, who did they hire first, and how did they set up processes for success? Look for someone who understands scaling their team, but also deeply understands revenue goals and company quota.

What are you looking for in answer? Someone who can outline with enough breadth and depth to tackle key points of revenue, growth goals (xxx ARR), scaling from early/founder-stage to being strategically led.

‍

2. Can you tell me about a specific sales or strategic initiative you’re particularly proud of? I’d love for you to walk me through initiation to the impact it made. 

‍

Every startup needs a VP of Sales who can create and execute a sales strategy, not just plug into one. They should be able to dive into at least 1-2 examples without being prompted further. But you could ask for examples or give context of how they’ve developed a strategy for a new product or market. Did they understand the ideal customer profile, build a repeatable sales process, or refine messaging based on feedback? Their response will tell you how they approach high-level planning and tactical execution.

‍

3. How have you used data to drive sales growth?

‍

Sales is just as much about process and rigor as it is about data. Ask how they track performance, identify bottlenecks, and decide what to change or when to pivot. A great VP of Sales will know their way around CRM systems, dashboards, and KPIs—and be able to tell a data-driven story to grow revenue or make recommendations to other executives or the board.

‍

4. How do you work with cross-functional GTM teams (e.g., sales, marketing, finance) to drive sales success and revenue growth?

‍

For a startup, alignment is everything. Sales can’t operate in a vacuum—they need to work closely with marketing to generate leads, with product teams to refine and iterate features, and with customer success to keep clients happy. Find out how they’ve built strong communication channels and avoided the “us versus them” dynamic. Bonus points if they’ve tackled misalignment head-on and turned it into a win for the company.

‍

5. Tell me about a time you had to pivot your sales approach—what happened, and how did you handle it?

‍

Startups are unpredictable, and a successful VP of Sales knows how to pivot when things don’t go as planned. Maybe a market shift rendered their original strategy ineffective, or a competitor disrupted their pipeline. What did they do? Were they able to strategize for the founders/other leaders? Did they reassess their ICP (Ideal Customer Profile)? Shift their pitch? Train their team differently? Their answer will reveal how they handle uncertainty and whether they can adapt without losing momentum.

‍

Closing Thoughts

‍

When interviewing candidates for a VP of Sales role, it’s crucial to evaluate not just their direct experience and problem-solving skills but also how effectively they articulate their strategic thinking and execution. A candidate's ability to recall successes and wins is important, but what truly sets them apart is how they tell their story. A well-structured narrative can elevate an average candidate into a memorable and compelling example of a strategic leader. Especially for a GTM leader. More on this here.

To assess this effectively, consider interpreting their responses through McKinsey & Company’s Situation-Complication-Resolution (SCR) Framework. This approach provides a clear structure for evaluating how candidates articulate their thought processes and achievements. By framing their experiences within this model, you can gain deeper insight into their strategic thinking and ability to tackle complex challenges.

Here’s how the SCR framework works:

1. Situation – The context or background of the challenge they faced.
2. Complication – The specific problem or obstacle that arose, making the situation more complex.
3. Resolution – The actions they took to address the complication and the outcomes they achieved.

Encouraging candidates to naturally align their responses with this framework will help you uncover not only what they accomplished but how they approached their work strategically. This lens allows you to differentiate candidates who are simply "good on paper" from those who can genuinely deliver impact at an executive level.

‍

Still Interviewing?

‍

Is your team already asking these questions and still can't find the right fit?

‍

Reach out, we can help.

‍